Fisher Phillips predicts Supreme Court will bar DOL from using ALJs to impose H-2A penalties in Sun Valley Orchards case
Key points
- Fisher Phillips predicts the Supreme Court will rule for the family farm in DOL v. Sun Valley Orchards
- The case turns on whether DOL's use of administrative law judges (ALJs) to impose H-2A penalties is constitutional, or whether employers are entitled to a federal judge
- The firm expects a final decision in 2027; the case is still pending
Law firm Fisher Phillips predicts the Supreme Court will rule for a family farm in the pending DOL v. Sun Valley Orchards case, ending the Labor Department's ability to use administrative law judges (ALJs) to impose H-2A penalties on agricultural employers.
The case turns on whether that practice is constitutional or employers are entitled to a federal judge. The firm expects a final decision in 2027. The case has not yet been decided. For reference only; not legal advice.
What employers should do
- Agricultural employers using the H-2A program should track the case and review their H-2A compliance records
- If you receive a DOL H-2A penalty notice, consult employment counsel promptly
Policy details
- Jurisdiction
- Federal
- Status
- Proposed rule
- Effective date
- —
- Employers covered
- H-2A agricultural employers
- Official source
- View official source ↗
Original report: Fisher Phillips LLP ↗AI-assisted brief; may contain inaccuracies. Rely on the original reports and official documents. For information only; not legal, immigration or insurance advice.
